The 20/20 Rule: The Minimalists’ Trick for “Just in Case” Clutter
“But what if I need it someday?”
That one sentence has saved a thousand junk drawers. It’s the reason the mystery cables stay. The reason the third garlic press survives every purge. The reason a drawer full of takeout menus and dead batteries gets to call itself “useful.”
Here’s the thing: “just in case” feels like prudence, but it’s usually just fear of future regret wearing a sensible coat. And once you see that, you need a way to argue with it — not with guilt, but with math.
That’s exactly what the 20/20 Rule gives you: two tiny questions that end the “just in case” debate in about thirty seconds.
Where the Rule Comes From
The rule comes from Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus — The Minimalists. They call it their “Just in Case Rule,” though most of the internet knows it as the 20/20 Rule.
Their logic is disarmingly simple. Most “just in case” items share two traits: they’re cheap, and they’re easy to get again. So instead of agonizing over every maybe-item, you run it through two questions. They report that the hypothesis has held up in their own lives — they rarely ever needed to replace a just-in-case item, and on the rare occasions they did, it was always cheap and fast.
The idea has traveled well beyond minimalist circles. Homes & Gardens has a pro-organizer explainer on it, HGTV included it in their roundup of clever decluttering ideas inspired by The Minimalists, and influencers have filmed themselves applying it to the most “just in case” place in any home — the junk drawer.
The Two Questions
For any item you’re keeping “just in case” — not using now, not loving, just… keeping — ask:
1. Can I replace it for under $20?
(UK readers: the rule travels as £20.)
2. Can I replace it in under 20 minutes from where I am right now?
That’s the whole test:
- Yes to both → let it go. If it’s cheap and fast to replace, the “just in case” isn’t protecting you from anything real. It’s renting space in your home for a scenario that probably never arrives — and even if it does, you’re $20 and a quick errand away from solving it.
- Yes to only one → slow down. Think harder, or park it in a maybe box (more on that below) with a calendar reminder. The rule isn’t a bulldozer; it’s a filter.

Notice what the rule does to the fear. “What if I need it someday?” stops being a bottomless dread and becomes a concrete, answerable question: could I rebuy this for twenty bucks in twenty minutes? Most of the time, the answer is yes — and the dread evaporates on contact with reality.
How to Run the 20/20 Rule (Step by Step)
The rule works best as a focused little session, not a whole-house marathon:
- Pick ONE zone. The junk drawer is the classic starter — it’s basically a museum of “just in case.” A bathroom cabinet or the cable-and-charger box are excellent second choices.
- Pull out every “just in case” item. Not the things you use. Not the things you love. Just the maybes — the items whose only job description is “might need someday.”
- Hold each one and ask the two questions out loud. Saying it out loud matters; it stops your brain from quietly upgrading a $6 item into a priceless artifact.
- Sort into three piles: let go (yes + yes), maybe box (yes to only one), keep (no to both — genuinely hard or expensive to replace).
- Get the let-go pile out of the house the same day. Bag it, box it, donate or trash it before the “just in case” voice renegotiates.
One drawer takes about twenty minutes. That’s the whole commitment.
The Maybe Box: For the “Yes to Only One” Items
Some items pass one question but not the other — replaceable for under $20 but a pain to track down, or quick to grab but oddly pricey. Don’t force a decision. That’s what the maybe box is for:
- Grab any box or bag and label it “Maybe Box” with today’s date.
- Put the borderline items inside, seal it, and put it somewhere out of the way (top of a closet, garage shelf).
- Set a calendar reminder for 30 days out.
- When the reminder fires: if you haven’t opened the box once, donate or discard the whole thing unopened. No peeking, no renegotiating — if you didn’t need it in a month, the “just in case” was fiction.

The sealed box is the genius part. It lets your brain release the item without the panic of permanence. You’re not throwing it away — you’re just… storing it somewhere inconvenient. Thirty days later, the evidence speaks for itself.
Where the 20/20 Rule Works Best

The junk drawer. The undisputed capital of “just in case.” Cables for phones you no longer own, batteries of unknown charge, rubber bands, ketchup packets, keys to nothing. Run the two questions over it and watch most of it fail both instantly.
Kitchen gadgets. The avocado slicer. The third spatula. The single-purpose tool you used twice in 2019. Almost all of it is under $20 and one store trip away.
Cables, chargers, and mystery cords. If you can’t name the device it belongs to within five seconds, it fails the spirit of the rule before you even ask the questions.
Closet “maybe” clothes. The jeans that might fit again, the top for an occasion that never comes. Under $20 to replace in most cases — and thrift stores exist.
Duplicate tools and craft supplies. The second hammer, the eleventh pair of scissors, the yarn for a project you abandoned two winters ago.
Where NOT to Use It
The 20/20 Rule is a scalpel, not a sledgehammer. Keep it away from:
- Sentimental items. No price tag fixes a grandmother’s recipe card. The rule measures replaceability, and some things are irreplaceable by definition.
- Genuinely expensive or hard-to-replace things. If it fails question one by a mile, the rule has already told you to keep it. Listen.
- Important documents, medical items, and safety gear. Passports, prescriptions, the fire extinguisher — these aren’t clutter, they’re infrastructure.
- Things you genuinely use seasonally. Holiday decorations and winter coats aren’t “just in case.” They’re “just in December.”
It Pairs Beautifully With Our Other Methods
The 20/20 Rule is a decision filter — it answers “should this stay?” Once you’ve decided what goes, our other methods handle the how:
- Need speed? The 12-12-12 method clears 36 items in about ten minutes.
- Drowning in maybe-piles? The OHIO method forces one decision per touch.
- Prefer to choose what stays instead of what goes? Reverse decluttering flips the whole process.
- Want a full-room sweep? Start with our weekend declutter list or the fall declutter checklist.
Think of 20/20 as the bouncer at the door: cheap, fast to replace, no strong feelings? Out you go.
FAQ
What is the 20/20 rule for decluttering?
It’s a decision rule from The Minimalists (Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus) for “just in case” clutter. For any maybe-item, ask: can I replace it for under $20, and can I replace it in under 20 minutes? Yes to both means you can let it go.
Who created the 20/20 rule?
Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus, known as The Minimalists. They originally called it their “Just in Case Rule” — the 20/20 name comes from the two thresholds: $20 and 20 minutes.
What if I can only answer “yes” to one of the two questions?
Don’t force it. Put the item in a labeled maybe box with today’s date, store it out of the way, and set a 30-day calendar reminder. If you never opened the box, donate or discard it unopened.
Does the 20/20 rule work in the UK?
Yes — UK coverage of the rule simply swaps the threshold to £20. The 20-minute half of the rule stays exactly the same.
What should I NOT use the 20/20 rule on?
Sentimental items, expensive or hard-to-replace belongings, important documents, medical and safety items, and things you genuinely use seasonally. The rule is for replaceable “just in case” clutter, not for everything you own.
Sources
- HGTV — Clever Decluttering Ideas Inspired by The Minimalists
- Homes & Gardens — What’s the 20/20 Rule for Decluttering
- Green Matters — The 20/20 Decluttering Rule Makes Cleaning Your Messy Junk Drawer So Effortless
Rule originated by Joshua Fields Millburn & Ryan Nicodemus (The Minimalists) as their “Just in Case Rule.” Framework described here in our own words.
